Paying employees to get healthy is a bad idea

I just discovered this brilliant whitepaper on employee wellness. It looks at a new worrying trend which has companies paying their employees to participate in wellness programmes.

This is of course an incredibly bad idea for many reasons, including these:

  • Financial rewards undermine autonomy
  • Employees who aren’t ready or willing to change… won’t
  • Financial incentives aren’t enough to change complex behaviors

It’s really, really time for companies to understand that financial rewards have several serious limitations as a tool to change employee behavior.

Related posts

Share this

Comments

5 responses to “Paying employees to get healthy is a bad idea”

  1. Ruth Avatar
    Ruth

    I found it funny that my employer the last 2 or 3 years has been offing $100 off my insurance premium if I take a health assessment online which is provided of course by my insurance provider. My employer wants to know how out of shape I am? What decisions will be made with this info? And does “confidential”l mean to them the same thing it means to me? HR has not been on the employee’s side for years so, ahem, I might be a little skeptical.

  2. Chad Avatar
    Chad

    Wow. If I didn’t know better, I’d say that the whitepaper was written in response to the health “rewards” programs that my company has implemented in the last few years. Just as the paper predicts, I’ve been able to hit the goals every year but I haven’t actually changed my lifestyle or become healthier.

  3. Jeanette Avatar
    Jeanette

    Now I am curious: did the companies pay employees to participate or did they pay for the wellness activity? To me the distinction seem significant! I agree so far if the employees are paid but if the company offer wellness activity as a benefit then I am not sure it has the same negative effect.

  4. Minnie Moore Avatar

    I’ve been off the employment world, the real one, for close to three years. My virtual work is not really covered by these kinds of benefits but I am not surprised at all. Even if it means spending their cash, as long as employers think that it would power up the productivity rate of their employees, they would go for it. That’s just my observation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Get our newsletter

“I can’t believe it – a newsletter actually worth reading!”
– Subscriber

Over 6,000 people subscribe to our newsletter with tons of tips about happiness at work.


Get our books

“It’s very, very good. It’s incredibly well written, full of insights, and there are exercises to improve your own happiness at work. You can’t ask for more than that!”
– David Maister, author of Practice What You Preach

“What an inspiring book. Every leader should read it. This type of leadership has been integral to our success and I know it will boost your results too.
– Garry Ridge, CEO WD-40 Company


Get Our Free Newsletter

Over 6,000 people already get our free newsletter with useful tips, videos, links and articles about happiness at work.
Subscribe to our newsletter here.